The Great Marshmallow Debate


I can imagine ya’all just couldn’t sleep last night waiting to hear which marshmallow won our Marshmallow Toasting Taste Off… no?

Ah well, I will cut the suspense anyhow 😉

This whole thing got started when I went to go pick up some run of the mill marshmallows at Walmart…

My childhood nostalgia kicked in and I went straight for the marshmallows of my youth that Kraft makes…

And low and behold I was shocked at the choices that sat on the shelf before me…

There were Chocomallows… Chocolate flavored of course.

And pillowy pink StrawberryMallows!

Caramel & Vanilla SmirlMallows…

And Toasted Coconut Marshmallows!

I was clearly a kid in a candy shop! I bought a bag of each (including the original)… leaving behind the smaller hot cocoa friendly flavors like chocolate mint … I see a marshmallow taste off sequel in my future… just sayin’

Anyhoo… After we got the campfire a blazing, Puddie, Monkey, Aunt Lou, Michael, Memaw, Papaw, Miss Add and I all got down to business — toasting and taste testing!

And the winners are…

Second Runner Up…

StrawberryMallow: Favorited by Miss Add, Second place by Mommy

First Runner Up…

Original: Favorited by Memaw and Mommy, Second Place by everyone else.

And the Marshmallow Taste Off Winner is…

Caramel & Vanilla SwirlMallow: Favorited by Aunt Lou, Uncle Michael, Puddie and Papaw and given second place by Memaw.

Honorable Mention goes to Toasted Coconut for being a great product for other purposes. Both Mommy and Memaw loved the coconut flavor and texture and thought they could be used creatively in the kitchen for a yummy twist on desserts.


Thanks again to Avant Garden Decor for giving us a lovely fire pit for our very important taste test findings 😉





About Cris
I am the mama behind GOODEness Gracious and the owner of Cris Goode Solutions. Here at GOODEness Gracious, we like to keep it light and fun as we cook up family meals, share our super mommy secrets and chat it up about the GOODe life:) So come on in and sit a spell.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
  • Ashley S

    WalMart also has HUGE marshmallows. They’re called Campfire marshmallows I think. They make the gooiest S’mores & are so big that you can roast them, pull off the outer layer and eat it, then toast the center again. Omigosh… Mmmmm. 🙂

  • Tina @ grammasinthekitchen

    I love the Coconut Marshmallows! Last year I found Gingerbread Marshmallows..sure hope they bring them back this year…they were great in hot cocoa!!

  • BigD

    I don’t buy the flavored ones–I just know that in THIS house, you have to buy JET-PUFFED only. No generics! Those are the only ones that taste good… or so says The Husband!

    • Anonymous

      I agree with the Husband!

  • Susan S.

    Susan S.

    I love your blogs…felt like I was at the campfire challenge!!  I vote for the originals!!

  • Lana

    We roasted the monster mallows in two or three stages:  Just kept pulling off the roasted part and sticking the rest back into the fire.   I need to check out these other flavors.  Hopefully we can have a few more fires in our ring before harvest and cold weather settle in.

  • Valerie Jackson

    How fun! We just moved into a new house, and the previous owner left behind a fire pit! Can’t wait to put it to use.

  • Valerie Jackson

    How fun! We just moved into a new house, and the previous owner left behind a fire pit! Can’t wait to put it to use.

  • Pingback: Backyard Entertaining for Labor Day Weekend | Love Your Yard()

Featured on: